The character on the tube is only the first clue

A familiar character can make this recall feel easy to identify: see Crayola, Barbie, Hot Wheels, or My Little Pony and throw the tube away. The actual task is more precise. FDA enforcement records list 17 separate Class II recalls covering particular Brush Buddies, BB, evo, and ARU toothpastes, with specific product descriptions, lot codes, and expiration dates. A matching brand name by itself is not enough; a different lot may fall outside the record.

The records cover 4,301,700 tubes distributed nationwide. Many are children’s flavored toothpastes, but the list also includes whitening, sensitivity, cavity-protection, and gum-health formulas marketed to adults. Treat this as a label-reading exercise: bring the tube into good light, keep the box if you still have it, and compare the identifying details line by line.

Start with the exact product, not the umbrella brand

The Brush Buddies group includes Barbie bubble gum, Hot Wheels strawberry, three Crayola Silly Scents flavors, My Little Pony bubble gum, four ice-cream flavors, whitening with baking soda, cavity protection cool mint, and advanced whitening peppermint. The remaining records cover evo Advanced Whitening and Sensitive toothpastes, plus ARU Gum Health and Cavity Protection formulas.

Names that sound similar can describe different products. Match the full name and flavor, then look for the NDC or UPC when the FDA record provides one. The Crayola bubble gum, watermelon, and strawberry tubes, for example, have separate product codes even though their listed affected lots overlap. Do not decide from package color, a marketplace thumbnail, or a shortened receipt description.

The lot code is the decision point

Find the lot code and expiration date on the crimp, tube, or carton. Photograph them before the packaging is discarded. In the FDA enforcement search, use recall event 99849 or the individual recall numbers D-0053-2027 through D-0069-2027, then open the record that matches the exact product. Compare every character; zero, the letter O, one, and the letter I are easy to confuse in small print.

The affected expiration dates span from November 2026 into June 2028, so expiration alone cannot confirm a match. A tube is included when its product identity and listed lot information align with the record. If the code is rubbed off or unreadable, contact the retailer or distributor rather than guessing. Keep the product separate from the family’s active toiletries while you clarify it.

Class II describes the risk category, not a diagnosis

FDA classified the recalls as Class II. The agency defines that category as a situation in which use of a violative product may cause temporary or medically reversible health consequences, or in which the probability of serious consequences is remote. That definition should not be rewritten as “no risk,” and it should not be inflated into evidence that a specific person has been harmed.

The listed reason is current good manufacturing practice, or CGMP, deviations. CGMP rules are the systems used to control manufacturing processes, facilities, materials, testing, and product quality. FDA also explains that a CGMP violation does not, by itself, prove that every unit has a visible defect or that a particular consumer will experience a problem. The public records do not identify a specific contaminant, so avoid filling that gap with rumors.

If the tube matches, preserve the useful details

Follow any instructions supplied by the recalling company or retailer. The enforcement records identify the products and distribution but do not provide one universal refund procedure. Before returning or discarding a matching tube, save photographs of the front label, UPC or NDC, lot code, expiration date, and receipt if available. Those details can make a retailer conversation or product-quality report far more useful.

Do not let the recall end the household’s oral-care routine. Use an unaffected toothpaste that is appropriate for the person using it and follow its directions; ask a dentist or pharmacist if age, swallowing, sensitivity, allergies, or a medical condition makes the substitute unclear. A recall article can help identify a product. It cannot choose an individual dental-care plan.

A past use is not proof of harm

Finding an included lot after someone has used it can be unsettling. Do not diagnose a reaction from the recall notice alone. If there are symptoms or a health concern, contact a dentist, physician, poison-control service, or other appropriate professional with the product details. For an emergency, use emergency services.

FDA’s MedWatch program accepts reports of serious reactions and product-quality problems involving human medical products. A report is most informative when it includes the exact product, lot, dates of use, what happened, and any clinical information available. Keep the tube and packaging unless a professional or official instruction tells you how to dispose of them.

Marketplace listings can outlive a recall notice

A product page, third-party marketplace, or resale listing may remain visible after a recall is classified. Do not treat “in stock,” a high rating, or a familiar character license as evidence that the offered lot is unaffected. Ask for the lot and expiration date before buying an older or clearance tube, and compare them with the current FDA record. If the seller cannot provide that information, leave the listing.

For products already at home, a five-minute cabinet check is more useful than scrolling through alarming summaries. Check every tube separately, including unopened backups and travel bags. Household members may have bought the same formula at different times, creating different lots under nearly identical packaging.

Keep a small recall habit after this one

For toiletries and over-the-counter products, save a quick photograph of the front label and lot code when you open a new multipack or family item. Keep digital receipts long enough to identify where it came from. This does not require turning the bathroom into an archive; one clear image can preserve the details that labels lose through handling.

When a recall appears, begin with the regulator’s current record, confirm the exact product, and follow the instructions attached to it. News reports can alert you, but the record should decide the match. The useful response is calm and exact: identify the tube, preserve the code, replace the routine if needed, and take a specific concern to the person or agency equipped to answer it.

Published by Spee24. Our editorial approach.

Explore Shopping